Breaking Free
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

For the debaters in here.. Let's discuss morals

who's talking here?

LelaBelle 1
Jersey Girl 7
Allen 1
Wallflower 1
Lovebug3 3
BoatsnHos 1
Loved living in Oki 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Does anyone remember the Terri Schiavo case?

We are talking about it in school and was wondering what you all think about it. It was a very high profile situation. We're talking about morals in this class.

If you don't know the story (maybe I'm just old and that's why I remember it) then read on.

Terri Schiavo entered a vegetative state in 1990 after adopting an "iced tea diet" (related to her bulimia), resulting in a disastrous potassium deficiency that caused irreversible brain damage. In this persistent vegetative state she remained the last fifteen years of her life. Both Schiavo's doctors and her court-appointed doctors expressed the opinion that there existed no hope of rehabilitation. Her husband, Michael Schiavo, contended that it was his wife's wish that she not be kept alive through unnatural, mechanical means. Michael Schiavo wanted her feeding tube removed, after which Terri would slowly die of malnutrition and dehydration. By this time Michael had taken a new lover, but refused to divorce Terri, as doing so would have forfeited his right to determine her care.

More than twenty times the Schiavo case was heard in Florida courts. Every time, the court ruled that the decision was her husband's to make, upholding the sanctity of marriage long respected by legal precedent. Schiavo's parents, Bob and Mary Schindler, refused to accept this verdict, feeling in their hearts that their daughter would somehow recover. Of this struggle, Schiavo's attorney, George Felos told the Associated Press, "The real grievance is not they [the Schindlers] did not have a day in court, that they did not have due process. The real grievance is they disagree with the result."

The Schindler family videotaped Schiavo for extended periods of time, discarding nearly all of the footage, and prepared a short but disingenuous "highlight" video featuring only the occasional moments when her facial expression looked vaguely like a smile, or when family members were posing where Schiavo seemed to be staring, giving the illusion of "eye contact."

In 2003, a court-appointed guardian for Schiavo wrote that during the protracted legal struggle, her parents had "voiced the disturbing belief that they would keep Terri alive at any and all costs", even if that required amputation of her limbs. "As part of the hypothetical presented", the guardian's report stated, "Schindler family members stated that even if Terri had told them of her intention to have artificial nutrition withdrawn, they would not do it."

Politicians inserted themselves into the fray. The case was the catalyst for Florida's controversial "Terri's Law", which gave Gov. Jeb Bush the authority to have Schiavo's feeding tube re-inserted when a court ruled that her husband could have it removed.

Terri's doctors opinion was that Schiavo's coma had been caused by a potassium imbalance triggered by her bulimia. Nutball "save Terri" activists knew better, and claimed she suffered a violent beating at her husband's hand. Her parents eventually agreed, and said that her husband often beat Schiavo when she was healthy -- but Schiavo never called the police, apparently never mentioned it to anyone, and her parents never mentioned it either until years after Schiavo was hospitalized. There is no evidence to support such claims.

The U.S. Congress quickly passed legislation allowing federal courts to intervene, and President George W. Bush flew back to Washington to sign the bill into law. It should be noticed that this is the same George W. Bush who, as Governor of Texas, signed into state law the power of hospitals to remove a patient (in identical situations as Terri's) from life support -- a critical factor being the family's ability to pay the hospital bills -- even if such removal was against the family's objections.

As the insanity moved to the federal level, Schiavo's feeding tube was finally removed on March 18, 2005, and her heart stopped beating 13 days later.

In a final postscript to Schiavo's short life, the autopsy conducted after her death established that her brain damage was even worse than experts had said while she was alive, and that virtually everything the "save Terri" activists had said was incorrect. Schiavo's brain weighed about half what a healthy human brain weighs, damage that left her unable to think, feel, see, or interact in any way with her environment. There was no chance she could have recovered, and no evidence she had ever been abused. 

Lovebug3 --- 15 years ago -

Which part of the case do you want to discuss? 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Well my opinion was that the husband had a right to make the decision he did. Courts ruled that he had the right several times.

The parents went on many talk shows including Larry King and said she was able to communicate. After she was dead, they found that it was worse than what they thought and that her parents were just holding onto her because it was their daughter.

The question from the teacher was:
View the CNN Pipeline news clip “Terri Schiavo’s Parents” located on the Materials tab of your student website for Week Eight. State your stance on the Terri Schiavo case, and identify the moral value judgment that influenced you to choose your stance.

To which I replied:
My moral stance on Terri Schiavo’s case is that her husband, Michael Schiavo was the legal guardian and therefore should be the one to decide on Terri’s behalf. Terri's parents are making the assumption that Terri had the same religious belief as them and were attempting to use those beliefs as legal grounds to keep Terri alive. Being that Terri was unable to communicate it was unknown what stance she had taken on either a pro-life or religious preference at that time. I would think that she had discussed these things with her husband in the result of something of this nature happening. I also remember hearing this case many years ago and even at the time in my teen years, I didn't believe that they should keep this woman on her feeding tube. It had been many years and even though the parents say that she can communicate, it wasn't happening. No, she was not brain dead but she had enough damage that her brain couldn't communicate and tell her body to swallow. I side with Michael Schiavo as legal guardian and I always have. I believe that sometimes it's time to move on and let what will happen - happen.

And then someone else said:
I must say that I definitely understand where you are coming from in the stance that the legal guardian should have the final decision on the fate of the person they are caring for but in my opinion this case is a bit different because it has to do with your perception of how you think Terri is functioning. In her husband's eyes he doesn't think she is functioning at a state where she should be kept alive but on the other hand her parents perception is that their daughter is functioning at a level of someone that has severe mental retardation and they are willing to make sure that she continues the medical treatment necessary to live the rest of her life. Non of us really know how much of Terri's brain is functioning but what if she does want to live but just can't speak the words? If any of us had a child that was born with severe brain damage would we simply just cut off their feeding tube and decide that they are fit to continue living? Just want your opinion.

To which I also replied:
If I had a child that was born brain dead, than no, I would not just cut off the feeding tube. I believe that - that is a completely different situation. The child never had a choice. The child never went on to live a "normal" life so it will never know the difference. From what I understand about the case (which I looked further into a long time ago when it was happening), the husband and her had had a discussion about things. Either way, I believe that the husband did everything he could (I believe this was over like a 10 year period of time) and stood by her the entire time. It got to the point where he felt that there was never going to be a way for Terri to live "normally".
Looking at it from his perspective, I see that sometimes you need to move on. He stood by her through everything. Why is it ok for him to stay married and not move on with his life? I understand that the parents were willing to take on Terri's care, but this man is/was in love with her and they had been together for a long while. I'm sure that he didn't want to just walk away and that this decision was very hard for him as well. As far as morals go, it's subjective based on each individual


And then I posted the link to the article that you read above. Most people think that the decision was wrong so I just wanted to see how others felt. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

This would happen if anything ever put my husband in a vegetative state. We have discussed it and I know he would not want to live that way but his mother would fight tooth and nail for him to spend the next 50 years like that, just so she wouldn't lose him.

In the Schiavo case, the docs did not believe she was ever going to get better and had given medical reasons as to why she sometimes (rarely, really) seemed to react to things which had nothing to do with her actually seeing or feeling anything. If Mr. Schiavo went out and found a girlfriend a couple weeks after Mrs. Schiavo ended up in the hospital, I would question his morals but after that long it ceases to be a moral issue, at least for me.  I would not want my husband to cease living simply because I had. 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

I couldn't agree with you more. My husband and I have a very similar plan. One that I have probably told no one else about.

If I have to live in a vegetative state, let me die. I would rather not be a burden. 

Lovebug3 --- 15 years ago -

If I have to live in a vegetative state, let me die. I would rather not be a burden.

This is exactly how I feel. Cases like this are why people need to fill out living will and health care proxys!! It is important to make YOUR OWN wishes known on paper in a legal manner. So the decision never becomes someone elses!! 

Lovebug3 --- 15 years ago -

I do have to disagree with you about the child being born brain dead though. I feel differently. If I knew my child would have no quality of life while pregnant I would terminate the pergnancy and if we found out after the child was born I would not have them on life support. Thats just my personal feeling on it though. And I respect that not everyone feels this way. I am also a big supporter of euthanasia though too. I watched my mom slowly die from breast cancer and it was awful. No one should have to suffer like that. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

I watched my mom slowly die from breast cancer and it was awful. No one should have to suffer like that.

My mom had Alzheimer's so I agree with you here. 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Lauren, I was just saying it would be a different situation for me. It would depend on the quality of life they would have. Not that I would never do it, that it would depend on tests and such.

I'm also a supporter of euthanasia. I can't understand why it's ok to euthanize animals but not people. 

Wallflower --- 15 years ago -

I can't understand why it's ok to euthanize animals but not people. 

^this^ 

BoatsnHos --- 15 years ago -

I can't understand why it's ok to euthanize animals but not people.

^this^


Ditto.


The only lack of morality I can find in this case is that government officials actively tried to interfere with the judicial process and attempted to "undo" the checks and balances that make our system of government great, and turned it into a campaign platform on which to run. 

Allen --- 15 years ago -

We should have helped Doctor Death escape, he would have put that poor dear out of her misery in 2 minutes. Disgusting is what I think. 

LelaBelle (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

I do have to disagree with you about the child being born brain dead though. I feel differently. If I knew my child would have no quality of life while pregnant I would terminate the pergnancy and if we found out after the child was born I would not have them on life support. Thats just my personal feeling on it though. And I respect that not everyone feels this way. I am also a big supporter of euthanasia though too. I watched my mom slowly die from breast cancer and it was awful. No one should have to suffer like that.

Agreed.

I can't understand why it's ok to euthanize animals but not people.

I believe that people should be able to be put out of their misery without having to actively shoot themselves in between the eyes. I'm a FIRM believer in assisted suicide and that it should be legal. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

People do not like to compare people and animals. They think it's as though you are saying animals are on the same level as humans. 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Well, there are certain ones that are pretty close.

There are animal rights activists that fight for them all the time.

I'm not an animal person (even though I allow them into my house for the kids) but I still wouldn't let my dog loose and hoped it never came back, like the other story.

The way I see it is if they are that similar to us, then why can't we be put out of our misery by our own choosing? The animal doesn't get to be euthanized because it wants to. It doesn't have a choice at all. We make the choice for them, much like Terri's guardian did. 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

Actually, I prefer animals to people most of the time. lol Mine go everywhere with us, have been with us since our first year of marriage and, yes, even sleep in our bed. But I do get a lot of "your dogs aren't like kids" from people. I realize they aren't human but I would like other people to realize that I would do as much for them (health wise, I'm not throwing them expensive birthday parties or anything) as anyone else would do for their child. But I think that people find it immoral to euthanize someone since that's something you would do to a pet because it's "just a dog" or "just a cat". 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Right now, I'd like to punch the computer screen and not go back to that class..

I'm the only person who thinks that it was his decision to make. The most recent response was:

I understand what you are saying. Yes, her husband was the legal guardian. If he felt it was a burden after those 10 years he could of just gave up the guardianship to her parents. Its good that he stayed by her all those years and it does show he cares for her and he did all he could but was it all he could do for her? It doesn't matter how her parents made a video of her when she had a good moment that was only limited. If her parents wanted to take care of her it should of been ok with the husband and it did not need any legal matter. The guardianship of the wife could of been given up easily with gladness the parents would of taken it. It is hard to tell someone what they feel about marriage really is and if they have been through horrible things then it will make one think a different way. Letting someone starve is the only thing that is going to happen if the tube is taken away and I wouldn't want to be starved. Not sure if you would.

To which I replied:

No, I would not like to starve to death. I would rather be euthanized, but that's illegal and a whole other debate topic 

Loved living in Oki --- 15 years ago -

She's brain dead. She has no idea if she's starving to death or eating eight course meals every day. 

Jersey Girl (Admin) --- 15 years ago -

Thank you LLIO!

I just can't discuss it with them anymore. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Breaking Free